Best Transfer Proof Lipsticks Every Woman Should Own

When it comes to transfer-proof lipsticks, finding one that lives up to its promise can be a game-changer. Today, we’ll be exploring four of the best transfer-proof lipsticks on the market to see if they truly deliver on their claims. The lipsticks we’ll be reviewing are the Dior Rouge Forever Liquid, Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint Longwear, Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink, and Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour. As a beauty enthusiast, I’ll be sharing my personal experience and impressions of these products, covering everything from packaging to performance. So, let’s dive right in and see how these lipsticks perform!

Understanding Transfer-Proof Lipstick

Transfer-proof lipstick is designed to minimize or prevent the transfer of pigment onto other surfaces, such as masks, cups, or utensils. While the concept is not new, it has evolved significantly over the years. Early transfer-proof lipsticks involved two-step processes with separate overcoats to seal in the color. However, modern formulations have improved, incorporating a complex blend of silicones, oils, and other ingredients for enhanced longevity and performance.

Testing Criteria

To provide a comprehensive review, I’ve established specific criteria for evaluating each lipstick. While this review may not be scientific, it covers essential factors that most people consider when purchasing transfer-proof lipsticks.

Mask Test

Given the current need for masks, this test examines how each lipstick holds up when wearing a mask. I’ll be assessing whether the lipstick smudges or fades when in contact with a disposable medical mask.

Coffee Mug Test

Hot coffee and lipstick don’t always mix well, leaving imprints on mugs. This test evaluates how each lipstick performs when sipping a hot beverage, checking for any residue left behind.

All-Day Wear

The all-day wear test is crucial for transfer-proof lipsticks that claim long-lasting performance. I’ll be wearing each lipstick throughout the day, including during activities and errands, to determine if they maintain their color and stay in place.

Dior Rouge Forever Liquid Transfer-Proof Lipstick

Product Overview

The Dior Rouge Forever Liquid Lipstick is a recent addition to the liquid lipstick range, featuring ten shades suitable for every skin tone. The brand claims that this matte liquid lip will last up to 12 hours while remaining weightless and comfortable on the lips. Additionally, it promises not to settle into lip lines or feather.

First Impressions & Application

The packaging of the Dior lipstick exudes luxury and elegance. The sturdy silver tube adds to its appeal and durability. Upon application, the lipstick glides smoothly, providing good color payoff without needing multiple dips into the product. The finish appears smooth, and there are no noticeable cracking lines.

Mask Test

The Dior Rouge Forever Liquid Lipstick holds up well during the mask test, leaving minimal residue even with frequent mask removal. This ensures that the lipstick stays intact without smudging or transferring onto the mask.

Coffee Mug Test

Even when enjoying a hot cup of coffee, the Dior lipstick shows impressive results, leaving minimal residue on the mug’s rim. This indicates that the lipstick withstands hot beverages without compromising its appearance.

All-Day Wear

Throughout the day, the Dior Rouge Forever Liquid Lipstick performs admirably, with only minor signs of fading and slight cracking. A quick touch-up or applying a silky gloss can easily rectify these minor imperfections.

Overall Experience

After thorough testing, it’s safe to say that the Dior Rouge Forever Liquid Lipstick lives up to its claims. It provides long-lasting wear, particularly when paired with a moisturizing lip primer. This lipstick is a worthy addition to any makeup collection, especially for those looking for transfer-proof options in the mask-wearing era.

Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint Longwear

Product Overview

The Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint is a weightless, long-wearing lipstick with a soft matte finish. It is available in 8 shades, including both nude and bold colors. The lipstick is vegan and free from parabens, making it a sustainable option. In this review, we will focus on the shade ‘Unattached,’ a bright coral color.

First Impressions & Application

The packaging of the Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint is sleek and luxurious, resembling a stiletto. The doe-foot applicator allows for precise and easy application. The lipstick applies smoothly, providing full coverage without the need for multiple dips into the product. The finish is smooth and the color is bold yet wearable.

Mask Test

During the mask test, the Stunna Lip Paint did not perform as well as expected. The color easily transferred onto the mask, resulting in noticeable residue on the inner lining. This lipstick may not be suitable for extended mask-wearing periods or cotton masks as it may leave stains.

Coffee Mug Test

The Stunna Lip Paint also left residue on the rim of the coffee mug, indicating some transfer of color. While it did not perform as well as desired, the amount of residue was relatively minimal compared to other lipsticks.

All-Day Wear

Throughout the day, the Stunna Lip Paint maintained its color and coverage, with only minor signs of fading and settling into lip lines. A quick touch-up or application of a glossy top coat can address any imperfections.

Overall Experience

The Fenty Beauty Stunna Lip Paint offers a beautiful color and finish, but it falls short in terms of transfer-proof performance. With strategic use, such as for evening wear or with the addition of a lip primer and liner, it can still be a worthwhile choice. As mask usage decreases, this lipstick may become a cult favorite for special occasions.

Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink

Product Overview

The Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink has been a popular choice for some time now, available in 40 shades. This lipstick claims to provide a flawless matte finish and last up to 16 hours. The unique arrow-shaped applicator allows for precise application.

First Impressions & Application

The packaging of the Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink is practical and prevents the lipstick from rolling off surfaces. While the shade ‘Dreamer’ appeared a bit light for the reviewer’s skin tone, it can work well with a full face of makeup. The application process was easy, and a matching lip liner can be used for enhanced precision. The lipstick provides full coverage without the need for a lip liner.

Mask Test

The Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink performed well during the mask test, leaving minimal residue on the inner lining of the mask. It held up to the challenge of mask-wearing, even in hot weather conditions.

Coffee Mug Test

The lipstick left a slight stain on the coffee mug, but the residue was significantly less compared to other lipsticks. The color remained intact on the lips despite the transfer.

All-Day Wear

Throughout the day, the Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink maintained its longevity, although some separation and settling into lip lines were observed. This is expected with a super matte finish. Layering the lipstick during touch-ups may result in a slightly cakey appearance, so it is best to avoid excessive layering.

Overall Experience

The Maybelline Super Stay Matte Ink impressed with its wide range of shades and long-lasting wear. While it showed some signs of wear and settling, it can still be a staple product for beautiful matte lips. Moisturizing lip primer can help alleviate any potential dryness, especially during winter months.

Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour

Product Overview

The Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour is a non-transferable lipstick that offers high shine and up to 16 hours of wear. It features a topcoat that adds shine without stickiness. The range includes 12 shades, and the product can be found at Nyx stores and well-known drugstores.

First Impressions & Application

The shiny topcoat of the Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour caught the reviewer’s attention, as it offers a glossy finish without the common issues of bleeding or imprinting. The two-step application process involves applying the color coat and then the clear glossy topcoat for maximum shine. The result is a beautiful and full pout.

Mask Test

The Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour passed the mask test with flying colors, leaving no residue on the mask despite its glossy finish. The lipstick stayed intact and did not transfer.

Coffee Mug Test

The coffee mug test showed minimal residue on the mug, demonstrating the lipstick’s ability to resist transfer. The glossy topcoat remained intact, adding to the overall appeal.

All-Day Wear

The lipstick’s all-day wear was impressive, with only slight wear in the inner part of the lips. The glossy topcoat eventually faded, but reapplication can easily restore shine and moisture.

Overall Experience

The Nyx Shine Loud Lip Colour left a positive impression with its long-lasting and glossy finish. Despite limited shade options and occasional availability challenges, it can be a go-to choice for those seeking a non-transferable lipstick with high shine.