Best Waterline Eyeliner Options: 15 Eyeliners I’d Trust With My Life

Best Waterline Eyeliner Options: 15 Eyeliners to Elevate Your Eye Makeup Game

Eyeliner has been an essential part of my makeup routine ever since I started experimenting with makeup. Given my larger eye size, I rely on eyeliner to define and accentuate their shape, particularly on the waterline. However, finding the perfect waterline eyeliner has been a challenge, as many tend to smudge or fade, leading to a less-than-desirable look.

Fortunately, my time at Sephora exposed me to some high-quality eyeliners that have proven to be smudge-proof and long-lasting, even on the waterline. These eyeliners not only offer rich pigmentation but are also available at various price points, making them accessible to everyone. Let me introduce you to the best waterline eyeliner options that can take your eye makeup to the next level.

My Top Recommendation: Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

Among the selection, my top pick is the Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil. Not only does it deliver impeccable pigmentation for the waterline, but you can also effortlessly apply it to your upper and lower lash lines, enabling you to create versatile and creative looks. The easy application and long-lasting formula make it a favorite. Though not entirely waterproof, it remains smudge-resistant, ensuring your eye makeup stays intact throughout the day.

Tips to Find the Perfect Waterline Eyeliner:

Before delving into my favorite waterline eyeliners, here are some tips to consider when choosing the ideal eyeliner for this delicate area.

Opt for the Right Color:

While black is a popular choice for the waterline, don’t be afraid to explore other shades like brown, green, blue, purple, and gray. White eyeliner can also be used to make your eyes appear larger.

Master the Art of Smudging:

To maintain intense eye makeup, smudging your eyeliner on the bottom lash line can be an excellent trick. This technique helps to keep your eye makeup bold even if the liner wears off from the waterline.

Waterproof vs. Regular Eyeliner:

Waterproof eyeliners are long-lasting and smudge-proof, but they may cause eye irritation for some individuals. Consider your preferences and eye sensitivity before opting for a waterproof formula.

Choose a Matte Finish:

Matte eyeliners are ideal for the waterline, as they do not contain shimmer or glitter that could irritate the eyes.

Stick to Pencil Eyeliners:

For the waterline, it is best to use pencil eyeliners (Kohl eyeliners) as gel or liquid formulas may sting or smear more easily.

How I Selected These Top Eyeliners:

In selecting these top eyeliners, I considered all the crucial factors mentioned earlier. All the products listed are in pencil formulas, safe for tightlining, and offer a matte finish. While black eyeliners are prioritized, a variety of colors is also included to suit different preferences. Some options are waterproof, while others are washable, providing choices for everyone.

Best Waterline Eyeliner Options:

Now, without further ado, let’s explore my favorite waterline eyeliners that promise exceptional results.

1.   Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil:
 Renowned for its versatility and long-lasting formula, this eyeliner comes in a range of attractive colors.

2.  Milani Stay Put Eyeliner:
An excellent drugstore option that boasts long-lasting wear and vibrant pigmentation.

3.  Fenty Beauty Flypencil Longwear Pencil Eyeliner:
Praised for its impressive color payoff and ease of application, offering a variety of shades perfect for the waterline.

4.  Charlotte Tilbury Rock n’ Kohl Eyeliner:
Intense and bold colors make this eyeliner ideal for those who prefer standout eye looks.

5.  Bobbi Brown Long-Wear Eye Pencil:
A richly pigmented eyeliner with a smooth gel-like texture, though some users report smudging issues.

6.  Inglot Kohl Pencil:
This velvety soft eyeliner is waterproof and easy to apply, but also washes off effortlessly with makeup remover.

7.   Laura Mercier Inner Eye Definer:
A versatile eyeliner available in various colors that is easy to apply and offers long-lasting wear.

8.  NYX Cosmetics Retractable Eye Liner Pencil:
A budget-friendly alternative to premium eyeliners, available in multiple matte shades for different looks.

9.  Shiseido MicroLiner Ink:
Loved for its smooth application and long-lasting formula, though it may not be suitable for those with sensitive eyes.

10.  Kulfi Beauty Kajal Eyeliner:
A creamy textured eyeliner with skincare benefits, catering to a diverse range of women.

11.  MAC Colour Excess Gel Pencil Eyeliner:
Highly pigmented and versatile, offering stunning color options, but some variants contain glitter.

12.  bareMinerals Mineralist Long-Lasting Eyeliner:
Known for its all-day wear, though it may smudge on oily eyelids.

13.  Jillian Dempsey The Brights Eyeliner:
A white eyeliner perfect for brightening the waterline, crafted with clean and vegan ingredients.

14.  Sephora Ultimate Gel Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil:
An affordable alternative to high-end gel pencils, available in various matte shades.

15.  Pat McGrath Labs PermaGel Ultra Glide Eye Pencil:
A highly pigmented gel pencil favored for its smooth application and versatility.