NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick Review & Guide: Do I Recommend This Popular Eyeliner?

The NYX Epic Wear Liner Sticks have been gaining popularity as one of NYX’s standout products. Known for their exceptional longevity and rich pigmentation, these eyeliner sticks offer an economical alternative to pricier brands.

As someone who previously tried NYX eyeliners without much enthusiasm, I approached these liners with some skepticism. However, I was pleasantly surprised by their performance. These liners exhibit remarkable pigmentation, particularly in shades like blue and green. What’s even more appealing is their affordability.

I’m even contemplating making a switch from my beloved Urban Decay 24/7 Liners (although Perversion will always have a place in my makeup collection). These liner sticks boast a sharp and robust tip, though it’s worth noting that some users have found them challenging to sharpen. For a more detailed insight into my experience, keep reading this NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick review & guide!

Bottom Line Up Front

Despite the common gripe about their sharpening difficulty, I wholeheartedly recommend these eyeliners. They outshine other NYX eyeliner products I’ve tested, offering impressive longevity without the need for constant touch-ups. I do suggest reserving them for occasional eyeliner wearers or those seeking vibrant and playful colors.

Pros:

• Exceptionally pigmented
• Budget-friendly
• Long-lasting, all-day wear
• Suitable for sensitive eyes without irritation

Cons:

• Challenging to sharpen

Key Features:

• Impressive 36-hour wear
• Rich pigmentation
• Waterproof and resistant to fading and transfer
• Available in 24 matte and metallic shades

About the NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick

Among NYX’s range of eyeliners, the Epic Wear Liner Sticks stand out as a personal favorite. These eyeliners are renowned for their ultra-pigmented formula, available in an array of colors encompassing matte, metallic, and shimmer finishes. NYX boldly claims a staggering 36-hour wear time for these eyeliners, which also boast smudge-proof, waterproof, and fade-resistant qualities. Notably, the eyeliners feature a sharp tip, facilitating the creation of diverse eyeliner looks.

My Review

Approaching these eyeliners with some uncertainty due to past experiences with NYX eyeliners, I was pleasantly surprised by the results. I decided to try two captivating shades: Turquoise Storm and Emerald Cut, with Turquoise Storm being my choice for last night’s outing.

Turquoise Storm proved to be the perfect shade of blue, delivering a vibrant and eye-catching look. Emerald Cut, while not as dark as my usual preference, can be best described as a neon green, offering a unique and attractive color.

Upon application, the standout feature was the remarkable color payoff. A single stroke sufficed to achieve intense and bold color—a stark contrast to my previous encounters with NYX eyeliners, which exhibited lackluster pigment. The texture and application of these liners reminded me of the Urban Decay 24/7 liners, not just due to the vivid hues but also the smooth and effortless glide during application. No excessive pressure was required, thanks to the sharp tip, which ensured a clean and precise line without any need for blending.

The durability of the tip allowed for experimentation with various eyeliner looks, including graphic styles. For my night out, I opted for a thin line on both my upper and lower lash lines.

Wearing the Liners

During my visit to a brewery last night, I put the Turquoise Storm eyeliner to the test. To my astonishment, it passed with flying colors—the eyeliner remained intact throughout the entire night. Frequent trips to the restroom allowed for periodic checks, and the liner exhibited no signs of running or smudging. Given my previous experiences with eyeliners running on me, this outcome was a delightful surprise.

Removing the Eyeliner

To remove the eyeliner, I employed two makeup removers: Ponds Cold Cleanser and Clinique Take the Day Off Cleansing Balm. Both effectively and effortlessly eliminated the eyeliner, leaving no residual traces.

Where to Buy the NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick

I procured my NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick directly from the NYX website. However, you can conveniently find these eyeliners at various other retailers, including:

• Ulta
• Amazon
• Target
• Walmart
• Walgreens
• CVS

Is the NYX Epic Wear Liner Stick Right for You?

My experience with the NYX Epic Wear Liner Sticks has been quite positive. These eyeliners impress with their exceptional pigmentation and smooth application. Nonetheless, it’s crucial to consider their drawbacks. Numerous users have voiced concerns about the difficulty of sharpening these liners. Therefore, I recommend these eyeliners primarily for those who don’t use eyeliner on a daily basis.

Another scenario where these eyeliners can shine is if you enjoy experimenting with unconventional colors that aren’t part of your daily routine. Personally, I reserve blue or green eyeliner for occasional use, perhaps donning such shades once every few months. In this case, if you encounter challenges while sharpening the liner, it’s a viable solution to simply purchase a replacement. Moreover, at a price point of $9 per pencil, it won’t strain your budget.

Other NYX Epic Wear Eyeliner Alternatives

While the NYX Epic Wear Liner Sticks offer notable advantages and drawbacks, if you wish to explore more options within the NYX range, consider the following NYX eyeliners. They may align better with your specific preferences and needs.

Epic Wear Liquid Liner

NYX presents its classic liquid liner, delivering the same advantages as the pencil version. These liquid liners are smudge-proof and boast remarkable durability. With an array of captivating colors at your disposal, you won’t need to concern yourself with sharpening these liners.

Epic Wear Metallic Liquid Liner

For those in pursuit of intense pigmentation and metallic flair without the hassle of sharpening, the liquid alternative is the way to go. These liquid liners inject drama into any makeup ensemble. Featuring a flexible brush, you can opt for a sleek line or a more elaborate eye-catching look. The liquid liners share numerous benefits with their pencil counterparts. They endure up to 36 hours without smudging or fading, outperforming competing products that might crack after prolonged wear.

Epic Wear Long Lasting Liner Stick Shimmer

If you’re seeking unconventional and funky colors, the Epic Wear eyeliners with shimmer are an excellent choice. NYX offers a palette of 14 glittering eyeliner shades to cater to your preferences. Notably, these shimmer-infused liners offer more advantages than the traditional matte Epic Wear eyeliners. They exhibit enhanced blendability, while retaining key benefits such as resistance to smudging, water, and fading. Moreover, they stand the test of 36 hours.

Jumbo Eye Pencil

My introduction to NYX products began with these beloved Jumbo Eye Pencils, featuring a cream-to-powder formula. They are perfect for creating sultry, smudged looks. NYX extends a selection of eight shades in both matte and shimmering finishes, granting you versatile options to experiment with.

Other Alternatives to the Epic Wear Liner Sticks

If you remain undecided about NYX liners, explore alternative brands that offer similar eyeliners.

Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Eye Pencil

While I adore NYX liners in vibrant shades, I reserve my trust for Urban Decay’s black eyeliner. Urban Decay, like NYX, provides an extensive color range. These eyeliners glide on smoothly and are easily smudged for a smoky effect. They offer lasting wear without smudging, yet it’s worth noting that, despite claims of waterproofing, they may not meet those expectations.

Sephora Collection Ultimate Gel Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil

When I’m in need of eyeliner and seeking affordability, I turn to Sephora Collection. While they may not match UD in pigmentation, they present an array of colors. These eyeliners do not smudge or run on me, and their twist-up design eliminates the need for sharpening.

Maybelline Unstoppable Mechanical Eyeliner Pencil

For those looking for a cost-effective option within NYX’s price range, Maybelline’s eyeliners are a compelling choice. Before I could indulge in UD products, Maybelline was my go-to drugstore eyeliner. Their application is smooth, and the staying power is commendable. While their color selection may not rival other brands, they still offer some playful shades like Sapphire.